Opening hours
Opening hours not available
We don’t have confirmed opening hours for Boxcar Barney's yet. Call (716) 222-9925 to check before you go.
Typical hours for ice cream shops in New York
Most ice cream shops in New York open around 11:00 AM and close around 10:00 PM on weekdays; 97% are open on Sundays and 61% stay open until 10 PM or later.
Based on 230 similar places in our guide.
About Boxcar Barney's
Looking for an ice cream shop in Mayville? Boxcar Barney's is at 13 Route 394, Mayville, New York. It is one of 6 places to eat and drink we list in Mayville.
You can visit for outdoor seating.
Phone: (716) 222-9925.
Quick facts
- Category
- Ice Cream Shop
- Address
- 13 Route 394, Mayville, NY 14757
- Phone
- (716) 222-9925
- Listing updated
- · Suggest an edit
Popular times (typical for ice cream shops)
Ice cream shops are usually busiest around 11 AM on Saturdays; one of the quieter times is around 8 PM on weekdays.
Based on typical visit patterns and the usual opening hours of ice cream shops in New York.
Typical prices for ice cream shops in New York
Based on 26 menus with 914 priced items from ice cream shops in New York, the median menu item costs $5.00, and half of all items are priced between $3.15 and $9.50.
We don’t have Boxcar Barney's’s own menu on file yet, so use these figures as a guide to what ice cream shops in New York typically charge.
| Item | On menus | Typical price |
|---|---|---|
| Vanilla | 31% | $5.25 |
| Banana Split | 31% | $11.75 |
| Milkshake | 19% | $9.00 |
Calculated from 26 menus in our guide. Prices vary by location and change over time.
Features & amenities
Service options
- Outdoor seating
The neighborhood
Within a 10-minute walk (half a mile) of Boxcar Barney's there are 2 other places to eat and drink in our guide, and 4 within one mile. By type, the places within a mile include Breakfast & Brunch (1), American (1), and Mexican & Tex-Mex (1).
Boxcar Barney's is the only ice cream shop within a mile (1 within three miles). The next closest is Lumi Cafe, 2.7 mi away.
Nearest places of other kinds
- AmericanShe Sings Cafe, Restaurant and Bar0.3 mi
- Breakfast & BrunchTulip's Brunch House0.4 mi
- Mexican & Tex-MexPueblo Real0.8 mi
- ItalianAndriaccio's Restaurant2.5 mi
What to expect at an ice cream shop
This group brings together bakeries, donut shops, ice cream parlors, frozen yogurt shops, dessert cafes, candy stores and specialty sweet shops. Bakeries usually open early and sell their best items before noon, while ice cream and dessert shops are busiest in the evening and on warm weekends.
What to order
- Croissants or morning pastries – freshest early in the day
- Donuts – classic glazed is the benchmark
- Cookies and cupcakes – easy to share or take home
- Pan dulce or Asian buns – bakery specialties from other traditions
Good to know
- Arrive early for the full selection; popular items sell out.
- Order celebration cakes several days ahead.
- Many bakeries discount day-old bread and pastries in the afternoon.
Reviews
Write a reviewNo visitor reviews yet. Been to Boxcar Barney's? Share your experience to help other diners.
Frequently asked questions
Where is Boxcar Barney's located?
Boxcar Barney's is located at 13 Route 394, Mayville, NY 14757.
What is the phone number of Boxcar Barney's?
You can call Boxcar Barney's at (716) 222-9925.
Does Boxcar Barney's offer delivery or takeout?
Delivery is not listed for Boxcar Barney's. Listed service options: outdoor seating.
What else is near Boxcar Barney's?
There are 4 other places to eat and drink within a mile of Boxcar Barney's. Nearby options include She Sings Cafe, Restaurant and Bar (0.3 mi), Tulip's Brunch House (0.4 mi), and Pueblo Real (0.8 mi).
Are there other ice cream shops near Boxcar Barney's?
None within a mile. The closest is Lumi Cafe, 2.7 mi away.
How much do ice cream shops in New York cost?
Based on 26 menus with 914 priced items from ice cream shops in New York, the median menu item costs $5.00, and half of all items are priced between $3.15 and $9.50.
Nearby places
All in Mayville
Listing data © OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL. Details may have changed – please verify with the business.